Well-known cricket writer
Makarand Waingankar rightly expressed his anguish recently over Tamil Nadu failing to win the Ranji Trophy on several occasions despite the presence of abundant talent in the State, with many players having represented the national team.
Waingankar observed that 23 players from Tamil Nadu had figured in Indian teams over the years. Unfortunatley, there were very few international games in the 1950s and 60s. A.G. Kripal Singh, a fine all-rounder, got the nod from selectors for about nine years (1955-64). His selection was sporadic more due to non-cricketing reasons than merit. For instance, he was chosen for the 1959 tour of England. He came up with a superb knock of 178 against fast bowlers like Brian Statham and Ken Higgs, while playing against Lancashire. Yet, players with much less talent, like J.M. Ghorpade and Aravind Apte, were preferred with disastrous results.
His younger brother Milkha Singh too suffered from limited opportunities. Recognised as a great left-handed batsman even by international players who saw him, Milkha got very few chances and was never given a look again after his failure in the Brabourne Test against England in November 1961.
There was also the graceful C.D. Gopinath who captained the Madras team and played a few Tests for India. His job with a high-profile company deprived him of turning up in more Tests. His non-availability due to office pressures was never understood in cricketing circles.
V.V. Kumar was the unluckiest bowler from the State. The late Polly Umrigar once told me that if he had continued as India’s captain, Kumar would have blossomed and developed into a fine traditional leg-spinner.
It was the ever-persevering Srinivas Venkataraghavan who earned a niche for himself in the minds of the selectors and even went on to captain India in two World Cups and a Test series. That he played from the age of 19 in 1965 to 38 in 1983 bears ample testimony to his hard work and passion for the game.
In the 1980s, cricketers like T.E. Srinivasan and Krishnamachari Srikkanth represented India. Srikkanth established himself as one of Sunil Gavaskar’s finest opening partners and lasted a dozen years. In the late 1980s, more Tamil Nadu players, like L. Sivaramakrishnan, off-spinner M. Venkatramana and W.V. Raman, got into the Indian team for the tour of the West Indies.
Sadagopan Ramesh, the gifted left-handed opening batsman, all-rounder Robin Singh, Raman and Hemang Badani were not treated properly. Badani’s foray into the ICL cost him his place in the State side despite his being one of the finest fast bowlers. To his misfortune, Virender Sehwag came rocketing into national reckoning displacing Ramesh. Even now, while watching some of the television clippings of games in which Ramesh batted, it is evident what an elegant and languid player he was.
Robin Singh grabbed the opportunity that he got. Players like fast bowler Lakshmipathy Balaji and Dinesh Karthik also got their national breaks. A back injury brutally affected Balaji’s progress. Sheer hard work and consistent performances at the domestic level helped Subramaniam Badrinath and Murali Vijay get into Indian teams in the last couple of years. But neither has made use of the opportunities as expected.
The players have talent no doubt and hence a recent spurt in the choice of Tamil Nadu players for the national side. But attitude is the problem. See the premature exit of such a talented player like Dinesh Karthik and the ‘wobbly’ performance of an opener like Murali Vijay. His feet movements, bat grip and body positions, all indicate his nervousness at facing fast bowlers. This was evident when he was opening for India early this year against South Africa in the Rainbow continent. Vijay’s performance in last domestic season 2010-11 was not too impressive either.
A very senior Mumbai-based cricket writer, who followed the India-West Indies Test series keenly, indicated that Vijay appears to have already resigned himself to the fact that he is unlikely to play for India again. Likewise, no one is talking about the need to include Dinesh Karthik in the Indian squad.
Abhinav Mukund, however, has shown signs of being the type of player that any side would be eager to have. The way that he has fought his way up the ladder on difficult pitches in the West Indies, and the Caribbean bowlers like Ravi Rampaul and Fidel Edwards, testifies to his advancement. At the domestic level too, Mukund has adapted himself to various formats of the game.
Indeed, Tamil Nadu has had gifted players, but the Ranji Trophy eludes them. The fault lies with the TNCA authorities. For some flimsy reason they replaced the talented and knowledgeable W.V. Raman as coach by a team of coaches and cricket managers. And it was a case of too many cooks. Raman was responsible for assiduously building up the Tamil Nadu side from the 2007-08 season. The team on two occasions won the Vijay Hazare limited overs cricket tournament. It is sad that a Test cricketer like Raman with good coaching skills should have been dumped. That’s probably the reason why Waingankar has called for the appointment of an international coach. The author had advocated a foreign coach for the Tamil Nadu team long ago till Raman came along.
Stalwart S. Venkataraghavan too could be roped in as an adviser as he will instil motivation into the minds of the players. At 66, Venkat would find it too demanding to stand in the hot, humid sun of Chennai to coach the players. Robin Singh would be my ideal choice as he is a great motivator and will set high personal standards. He’ll make sure the players can’t take their places for granted, as many do.
They need to realise that there is a huge gap in playing standards between the Tamil Nadu league circuit and the Ranji level. A good coach can help them bridge the gap.
Apparently after B. Arun, V.B. Chandrasekhar and Raman, the cupboard seems to be bare. As already said, talent in Tamil Nadu is in abundance, but it has to be harnessed properly. If the President and the senior office-bearers can put their heads together to get good coach – even a young local person – it would go a long way to build State side into a winning outfit. – (Courtesy: Straight Bat.)
Back to top
|